Color Issue

I create two cylinders and color them red & blue. Then I slightly merge then and do a Union of both. ABDC0938-96A9-49F2-98CB-49CCB1115762

To the extent that the two cylinders are not merged in form, I want the two top faces to also be red and blue. So I drew a line across this and indeed it shows two separate faces.

6A24F694-5DEA-4782-886E-44024DF99047

The Color tool states Select Faces, Bodies or Groups to color. But nothing happens for my Face and I get the following error message.

1A4CFAE2-98F7-41B9-98B9-4268A6D46AD9

You can’t change the color of an edge, sketch or sketch filling.

So is the Tool instruction message incorrect or is something not working correctly? Or am I misunderstanding something?

Thanks,

Tommy