Just a suggestion, but a little nicer tone is probably appreciated by the folks at Shapr3D.
Yes, your feedback is useful, but the title and demands for new management are a little harsh. In my experience, they take every bit of feedback to heart. There are a lot of amazing and significant changes happening to the app…not every one is perfect. But behind the scenes is a group of dedicated developers, and they are listening. And the Gamma group is giving constant feedback on those changes, so there is representation from a group of users to beta test those changes before they go live.
Anyway, give constructive feedback…I know it’s appreciated.
So, you’re saying my observations of the update that came out TODAY are false? I have thousands of hours and over a year of using Shapr daily. I am not making it up:
This never existed until today:
guess what happens when you hit enter during a copy, move, or align?
To answer the cooments by Curly - when a release comes out and breaks the working software in such a devastating way, it is time to look at it as a management issue.
No, you see the question mark? This indicating that I, IMHO, as a newbie with 12.000+ hours could not see it . Nothing is falsified. (Activating my BT numpad with Enter key [black rectangle] to establish a probability.)
Lets go for Copy then;
Gamma, Copy; click Void, click Done, Return, Enter, all same result
You can click on BLANK space, Any Item, or Done button. For copy, the done button is an addition but didn’t replace the previous behavior. For other tools, clicking BLANK space is like pressing the Done button but clicking on other Item is tool dependent.
Moving Union to a sub menu was intentional?
I think this depends on display size and/or platform b/c union is not in a submenu on my iPad 13" on the latest version. Either way, I had a similar reaction when some of my frequently used tools shifted location due to new features. Unfortunately, this will remain the case unless/until customized tool bars are supported.
Not allowing align immediately after a copy move while the parts are still highlighted is intentional?
Yeah, this one got me since I used this workflow a lot. I’m crossing my fingers that the upcoming alignment improvements will negate this issue. If not, we would like the align tool remain after copy as it simplifies the workflow.
PS I share your frustration but also believe they are trying a lot harder than in the previous year or so to address user’s concerns. It is important to point out behavior new or old that slows down human interaction with the tool whether it’s perceived or true. If it’s perceived, like the copy behavior, it either means we missed the release notes or it wasn’t adequately communicated to us. That’s valuable info for the developers.
It is working again after a quick update from them today. Earlier, if i made two copies and clicked in blank space like i have for over a year, it would erase my copies. It is working again and i have no idea why they they added this confirm step at all. Isn’t that what the undo arrow button is for LOL.
They should focus on important items like letting us customize our tool menu.
I’m not exactly sure but consider the case when you don’t have any visible space to click on… An explicit control that is always there to rely on is a good thing for me. I’m not 100% on board with the location of it though. Button transparency often makes it difficult to find.
I was a little taken back by the need to hit the done. But actually I like the way it works. It saves me from myself. That with the cards is pretty intuitive. Extra click sure.
So yesterday I made a simple bracket system for my filament switch and used posts. Mistake. This morning redesigning with screws. Being the addle brained ADHD I would have made one hole with threads then clicked on the other hole and added threads as a second operation. Now? Click on the other hole and magic threads appear. OMG so much better!
Okay so How do I get a bit of tolerance for 3D printed threads vs other materials Shapr? Guess I should print this before asking.
You are describing what must be inherent in gamma testing, surely? There will necessarily be changes, new features, and a degree of experimentation, that interact with this community. We get to be involved in the development process, with the opportunity to potentially contribute to shape it. There are downsides of the gamma versions for those whose work requires a higher level of consistency in the behaviour of the app.
What is your suggestion as to how to address the issues you have raised?
The back and forward arrows are a worldwide set of tools to undo and redo steps. Why do we need a nanny confirm step “to save yo from yourself”? Yo already have “Undo”.
Still, applying threads to one hole and before the operation is done, clicking another hole, without having to select the thread tool again I have threads? I like it. The done button is an extra step but in the long run, at least for me, it will mean better results better experience with less undo. Add the cards to that?
I associate the nav arrows for exactly that. Navigation to good effect.
Other CAD software works this way.
Shapr is still one of the fastest tools for fleshing out projects quickly.
Hold their feet to the fire. Releasing threads without tolerances was not ideal. Sure there are workarounds. I can live with that, but then nothing I do is mission critical. Sure there are other things they should have.
Truthfully I am representative of the hobbyist modelers here. Those just starting out, maybe without higher educations, but still have the need to get designs done without having to learn to be professional draftsmen using traditional design techniques.
If you look at Shapr’s history, initially a simple direct modeler, that is in my mind who it was originally for, or at least who it worked best for.
Shapr is still a unique product. Still one of he fasted tools to learn and easiest to flesh stuff out. Especially for the price point.